Semalt Platform — Competitor analysis

Reading your Glasgow competitors' playbook without them clocking on

“They rank page one” is a note, not intelligence. What put them there? Which links, which keywords, which pricing tweak on Tuesday? Answer those and the West End sits with the Barrowlands: two rooms, one crowd, and you already know which door people are queuing at. The competitor engine inside Semalt tracks the backlink gap, the keyword gap and the weekly change diff automatically — no scraping, no spreadsheets, no waiting on the next agency report.

Read time: 13 minLevel: Competitive strategyUpdated:

Contents

  1. Backlink gap: what your Glasgow rivals have earned that you have not
  2. Keyword gap: the terms they rank on and you don’t
  3. Change monitor: knowing when a competitor moves
  4. Local directory audit: Yell, Cylex, Glasgow Live and friends
  5. Editorial monitoring: The Herald, STV News, BBC Scotland
  6. Case study: Southside dental clinic vs. three rivals
  7. Semalt vs. Ahrefs vs. Semrush for competitor work
  8. FAQ
380MBacklinks in UK index
7dMedian change-detection lag
18Glasgow directories tracked
240UK editorial sources monitored
Live backlink graph Weekly keyword-gap refresh Copy-change diff Local citation tracker Editorial mention monitor UK GDPR compliant Alerts via email, Slack, webhook

Semalt’s UK backlink index sits at roughly 380 million links, refreshed on a rolling seven-day cycle. Point it at your domain plus three rivals (ten on paid) and it builds the comparison graph in seconds. Not a count. A gap — categorised, ranked by expected authority transfer, tagged with a difficulty score and a pitch template that’s worked before. A Skyscanner-adjacent Glasgow SaaS running this against FreeAgent and Craneware usually finds the same thing on the first run: three or four links sitting in plain sight, a Herald business column mention here, an industry directory listing there, all won inside a fortnight. The gap isn’t hidden. It’s just never been looked at properly.

For a Glasgow SaaS scale-up benchmarking against Skyscanner, FreeAgent and Craneware, the gap analysis routinely surfaces link opportunities that were sitting in plain sight — a listing in an industry directory, a guest post on a tech blog, a coverage piece in the Herald’s tech column. The engine tags each opportunity with a difficulty score (how easy is this link to earn?) and a template (what pitch worked historically for similar profiles?).

🔗

Referring-domain gap

Domains linking to two of your three competitors, but not to you. Almost always winnable.

🎖

Authority transfer forecast

Predicted change in your Semalt Authority score if you win a given link, based on historical acquisitions.

🔑

Anchor text audit

Detects unnatural anchor patterns that would trigger a link-spam penalty under Google’s SpamBrain updates.

📌

Lost-link recovery

Links you used to have and don’t any more — often a 404 fix or a broken redirect away.

Keyword gap: the terms they rank on and you don’t

Every Monday morning Semalt refreshes the keyword universe for the domains you track. The gap view answers three specific questions: which terms do all your competitors rank on (must-have terms); which terms do exactly one competitor rank on (opportunity terms, often the differentiator); which terms are you ranking on but nobody else is (protect this content, and understand why the moat exists).

The most under-used view is the “must-have” quadrant. If three Glasgow retail rivals all rank in the top ten for “click and collect Buchanan Galleries” and you are on page four, that is not a content gap — that is an existential product-page problem worth flagging to the merchandising team. Semalt lets you push the finding straight into a Linear or Jira ticket via the native integration.

Weak: manual competitor spreadsheet

Marketing analyst pulls three CSVs from Semrush every quarter, VLOOKUPs the difference, calls out the top twenty. By the time the report lands, the SERP has moved.

Strong: continuous Semalt gap monitor

Gap refreshes weekly. New terms your competitors have appeared on in the last seven days are flagged. Every finding lands as a Slack notification with a link to the SERP snapshot.

Change monitor: knowing when a competitor moves

A Glasgow restaurant group changing its delivery radius, a fintech competitor quietly pushing a pricing page from “from £29” to “from £39”, a rival law firm publishing a new landing page for a specific dispute type — these are the moves that reshape a SERP over the following month. Semalt’s change monitor takes a rendered screenshot and a text diff of every tracked competitor URL on a weekly cadence. It alerts you the moment content, title, H1, structured data or pricing changes.

Day 0

Baseline capture

Full DOM, screenshot and structured-data snapshot for every competitor URL you track.

Weekly

Diff pass

Rendered page compared line by line. Cosmetic changes filtered; substantive changes surfaced.

On change

Categorised alert

Tag applied: pricing, copy, product, structured data, navigation. Routed to appropriate channel.

Follow-up

SERP consequence report

Two weeks after a competitor change, Semalt reports the observed ranking movement caused by that change.

Local directory audit: Yell, Cylex, Glasgow Live and friends

Local SEO in Glasgow still runs partly on citations. The core directories — Yell.com, Yelp UK, Cylex, Scoot, Thomson Local, FreeIndex, Bing Places, Apple Business Connect — plus the specifically Glasgow-oriented outlets like Glasgow Live business listings and the Glasgow Chamber of Commerce directory each carry weight. Semalt’s citation tracker checks whether each competitor is listed, with what NAP data, and whether the entries are consistent.

Citation coverage across 18 Glasgow directories (typical sample)

Competitor A17 of 18 listings
Competitor B11 of 18 listings, 3 with wrong postcode
Your site (typical starting point)6 of 18 listings, 2 with old phone

NAP inconsistency is the silent local-pack killer

Google’s local ranking algorithm penalises NAP (name, address, phone) inconsistency across citations more heavily than most Glasgow marketers realise. A single directory with an old landline number can suppress your ranking in the map pack by two to three positions. Semalt flags every mismatch.

Editorial monitoring: The Herald, STV News, BBC Scotland

Beyond directories, the reputational side of SEO is driven by press mentions. Semalt monitors 240 UK editorial sources for mentions of your brand and your competitors, with heavy Scottish coverage: The Herald, Glasgow Times, STV News, BBC Scotland, The National, Scotsman, plus trade press for retail, food, tech, professional services and construction.

Every mention is scored for sentiment (positive, neutral, negative) and tagged with topic (product launch, funding round, controversy, expansion, hiring). A weekly digest lands in your inbox at 07:00 on Monday. For competitor mentions the digest includes a “response opportunity” flag — if a rival gets negative coverage on a topic where you can position positively, you see it that morning. Log in to configure your alerts.

Case study: Southside dental clinic vs. three rivals

A Southside dental clinic operating from a Shawlands practice engaged us in December 2025. They were competing with three other clinics within a two-mile radius. Their new-patient inflow from Google Business Profile had halved over the previous year. The owner assumed Google’s local algorithm had “changed the rules”. Semalt’s competitor analysis showed something more specific.

The remedy took eight weeks: two new treatment pages, fifteen citation fixes, three targeted link-building campaigns and a rebuild of the emergency-appointment page. By March 2026 the clinic was back to top-three positioning across all four target queries in G41 and G42, and monthly new-patient enquiries were up 62% versus the trough.

“I thought I was being punished by Google. It turned out I was being outworked by the practice two streets away. Semalt made that visible in an afternoon.”

Principal dentist, Southside dental clinic

Semalt vs. Ahrefs vs. Semrush for competitor work

Ahrefs

$129/mo
  • Deep backlink index
  • Content Explorer
  • Site Explorer

Gaps: no UK editorial monitor, no Glasgow directory pack, no rendered copy diff.

Semrush

$139/mo
  • Keyword Gap tool
  • Backlink Gap
  • Media Monitoring add-on

Gaps: media monitoring is US-first, no NAP consistency check.

CapabilitySemaltAhrefsSemrush
UK backlink graph✓ 380M✓ global✓ global
Weekly keyword-gap refreshMonthlyWeekly (paid tier)
Rendered copy-change diffNoPartial
Glasgow directory tracker✓ 18 sourcesNoPartial (US-first)
NAP consistency checkNoAdd-on
UK editorial monitor✓ 240 sourcesNoMedia Monitoring add-on
Slack / Linear routingPartialPartial

Our rule with Glasgow clients

Set up competitor tracking on your top three rivals within the first week. The weekly digest — backlinks earned, keywords gained, pages changed, mentions received — becomes the single most-read email in the marketing team’s inbox. Six months in, the digest quietly rewrites your content calendar.

FAQ

How many competitors can I track?

Three on the free tier. Ten on Growth. Fifty on Enterprise. For most Glasgow SMEs, three is the correct answer — a rigorous focus beats a scattergun watch. Set up your first three today.

Does the change monitor cover apps and Google Business Profiles?

It covers competitor websites and their Google Business Profile listings (opening hours, service list, primary category, reviews). Native app changes are outside scope.

Can I export the backlink gap to my link-building tool?

Yes. Native exports to BuzzStream, Pitchbox, Respona and generic CSV. Every opportunity ships with the pitch template the engine recommends.

How is sentiment scored for editorial mentions?

A fine-tuned classifier trained on UK press. Accuracy is 89% F1 against human labellers on a Scottish news sample. Every mention includes the sentence that drove the score, so you can override.

Does it monitor podcast mentions?

For UK business podcasts, yes — we transcribe the top 400 UK business podcasts weekly and mention-match. Podcast mentions are tagged separately from written editorial.

Does it feed AutoSEO?

Yes. Copy changes and new pages spotted on competitors feed AutoSEO’s content brief generator, so you can respond within days rather than weeks. See AutoSEO.

Verdict

Backlinks, keywords, pages and press — the four dimensions of competitive SEO. Semalt is the only UK platform that monitors all four continuously and routes findings straight into your workflow.

Get your first competitor gap report tonight

Free tier includes three competitors, full backlink and keyword gap, and Monday morning digest. Fifteen minutes to set up.

Sign in and benchmark →

Know your Glasgow rivals better than they know themselves

Free account, no credit card. Add three competitors and receive your first weekly digest on Monday.

Sign in to Semalt →